Ecommerce

How to Change Fulfillment Settings on Shopify: A Comprehensive Guide

June 9, 2025
9 min read

Introduction

Did you know that nearly 30% of online shoppers abandon their carts due to high shipping costs and unclear fulfillment policies? This statistic underscores the importance of having a well-structured fulfillment process in your Shopify store. Optimizing your fulfillment settings can make a significant difference in both customer satisfaction and overall business efficiency.

As ecommerce continues to flourish, understanding how to manage fulfillment effectively is more crucial than ever. The fulfillment process is not just about shipping products; it encompasses everything from inventory management to customer communication. Here at ShipAid, we recognize that every package matters, and robust shipping protection is key to enhancing customer trust and driving revenue.

In this blog post, we will explore the ins and outs of changing fulfillment settings on Shopify. We will guide you through selecting appropriate fulfillment methods, setting up manual or automatic fulfillment, and assigning fulfillment services to your products. By the end of this post, you will have a comprehensive understanding of how to tailor your Shopify fulfillment settings to fit your specific business needs.

We will break down the content into manageable sections, ensuring clarity and depth in our explanations. From the basics to more advanced strategies, we’re here to empower you in creating an efficient and customer-friendly fulfillment process.

Understanding Fulfillment: The Basics

Fulfillment refers to the entire process of receiving, processing, and delivering orders to customers. In the context of Shopify, it involves several key components:

  1. Inventory Management: Keeping track of stock levels to ensure that products are available for fulfillment.
  2. Order Processing: The steps taken to prepare an order for shipment, including picking, packing, and labeling.
  3. Shipping: The actual logistics of getting the package to the customer, which may involve a third-party carrier or an in-house team.

Properly managing these components can significantly enhance your customer experience and ultimately lead to repeat business.

The Importance of Fulfillment Settings

Your fulfillment settings play a pivotal role in how efficiently you can process orders. They allow you to customize the way orders are handled in your store, affecting everything from shipping speed to customer communication. For instance, you can choose between manual and automatic fulfillment, each with its advantages depending on your business model.

By adjusting these settings, you enhance customer trust and satisfaction, as customers are more likely to return to a store that reliably delivers their products on time and in good condition. This is where our mission at ShipAid aligns perfectly with the needs of ecommerce merchants. We believe that robust shipping protection not only safeguards shipments but also converts lost packages into profits through our innovative Delivery Guarantee model.

Step 1: Choose Your Fulfillment Methods

When setting up your fulfillment processes, the first step is to select the fulfillment methods that best align with your business needs. Shopify offers several options:

Fulfill Your Own Orders

If you’re running a small or new business, you might opt to fulfill orders yourself. This method allows you to maintain control over the packaging and shipping process, ensuring that your products arrive at your customers’ doorsteps just as you intended. Here are some benefits:

  • Cost-Effective: Fulfilling orders yourself can save money, especially if you’re just starting out.
  • Customization: You have full control over how products are packaged, which can enhance brand identity.

However, fulfilling your own orders can be time-consuming, especially as your order volume grows.

Use Third-Party Fulfillment Services

For businesses with higher order volumes or those seeking to streamline operations, third-party fulfillment services can be an excellent choice. These services take care of storage, packaging, and shipping, allowing you to focus on other aspects of your business. Here are the two main types of fulfillment services:

  1. Fulfillment Services that Integrate with Shopify: These services sync directly with your Shopify admin, allowing you to manage orders seamlessly.
  2. Custom Fulfillment Services: If your fulfillment provider does not have a direct integration with Shopify, you can still utilize their services by sending them order details through email.

Using third-party services can help you save time and potentially lower shipping costs, but it’s essential to choose a reliable partner that aligns with your business goals.

Key Considerations

When selecting fulfillment methods, consider the following:

  • Order Volume: Higher volumes may necessitate third-party services.
  • Customer Expectations: Faster shipping times may require a more automated approach.
  • Cost: Evaluate your budget for fulfillment services versus self-fulfillment.

Step 2: Choose Manual or Automatic Fulfillment

After selecting your fulfillment methods, the next step is deciding whether to fulfill orders manually or automatically. This choice affects how and when orders are processed in your Shopify store.

Manual Fulfillment

With manual fulfillment, you have complete control over the order processing timeline. Orders remain in an “Unfulfilled” status until you manually mark them as fulfilled. This method might be ideal if:

  • You need to ensure quality control during the packing process.
  • You offer customizable products that require specific handling.
  • You want to keep a closer eye on inventory levels before shipping.

While manual fulfillment gives you greater oversight, it can also slow down order processing times, which could impact customer satisfaction.

Automatic Fulfillment

On the other hand, automatic fulfillment allows orders to be processed as soon as they are paid. This method is beneficial for businesses that:

  • Use fulfillment services that can handle orders automatically.
  • Sell digital products or items that do not require special handling.
  • Want to streamline operations and improve shipping speed.

To set up automatic fulfillment, you’ll need to adjust your order processing settings in Shopify. However, keep in mind that this method may not be suitable if you need to package items yourself, as it could lead to confusion about which orders need shipping.

Making the Change

To change your fulfillment settings to automatic, follow these steps:

  1. From your Shopify admin, go to Settings > General.
  2. In the Order processing section, select Automatically fulfill the order’s line items.
  3. Optionally, choose to notify customers of their shipments.
  4. Click Save.

By optimizing your fulfillment settings, you can ensure a more efficient order processing experience for both you and your customers.

Step 3: Assign Fulfillment Methods to Your Products

Once you’ve established your fulfillment methods and processing preferences, the next step is to assign these fulfillment methods to your products. This allows you to customize how each product is handled based on your inventory management strategy.

Setting Fulfillment Methods for Individual Products

When adding or editing a product in Shopify, you can specify which fulfillment method to use. Here’s how:

  1. Navigate to Products in your Shopify admin.
  2. Select the product you want to edit.
  3. In the Inventory section, choose the appropriate fulfillment service from the Inventory will be stocked at dropdown menu.
  4. Click Save.

Bulk Editing Fulfillment Methods

If you have multiple products that require the same fulfillment method, you can use the bulk editor to save time. Simply select all relevant products, click on the Edit products button, and adjust the fulfillment method for all selected items simultaneously.

Managing Multiple Locations

If you manage inventory across multiple locations, Shopify allows you to fulfill orders from various sites. This flexibility can help you efficiently manage stock and reduce shipping times, ensuring that your customers receive their orders promptly.

Step 4: Fulfill Your Orders

Now that you have your fulfillment settings configured, it’s time to start fulfilling orders. The process will vary depending on the fulfillment method you’ve chosen.

Fulfilling Orders Manually

If you opted for manual fulfillment, here’s how to fulfill your orders:

  1. Go to the Orders section in your Shopify admin.
  2. Select the order you wish to fulfill.
  3. Click on Fulfill items.
  4. Add tracking information if applicable and click Fulfill items again.

Fulfilling Orders Automatically

For those using automatic fulfillment, orders will be processed without any manual intervention once payment is received. Ensure that your fulfillment service is properly set up to handle these requests automatically.

Handling Partial Fulfillments

If you need to fulfill only part of an order, Shopify allows you to mark items as fulfilled individually. This can be particularly useful for orders that contain multiple products or when certain items are on backorder.

Keeping Customers Informed

Regardless of your fulfillment method, keeping customers informed is crucial. Sending emails to notify customers when their order has shipped enhances the customer experience and builds trust. Make sure to enable notifications in your settings to ensure customers receive updates.

Conclusion

Changing fulfillment settings on Shopify is a crucial step in optimizing your ecommerce operations. By understanding the different fulfillment methods, choosing between manual and automatic fulfillment, and assigning methods to your products, you can create a streamlined process that enhances customer satisfaction and drives revenue.

At ShipAid, we believe that every package matters. By implementing robust shipping protection solutions alongside your fulfillment strategies, you can safeguard shipments and convert potential losses into profits through our Delivery Guarantee.

As you navigate the complexities of order fulfillment, remember that well-informed decisions can lead to improved customer trust and loyalty. If you’re ready to explore how our shipping protection solutions can empower your ecommerce business, we invite you to experience our interactive demo here or install our free-to-use app here.

FAQ

What is the difference between manual and automatic fulfillment in Shopify?

Manual fulfillment requires you to fulfill orders manually, allowing for greater control over the process. Automatic fulfillment, on the other hand, processes orders as soon as payment is received, which can speed up shipping times.

How do I set up fulfillment services in Shopify?

To set up fulfillment services, go to Settings > Shipping and delivery in your Shopify admin. From there, you can add fulfillment services and assign them to your products.

Can I change fulfillment settings after an order has been placed?

Yes, you can change fulfillment settings for future orders, but changes will not affect orders that have already been placed.

How do I know which fulfillment method is best for my business?

Consider factors such as your order volume, shipping speed requirements, and whether you want to manage packaging personally. Each business is different, so assess your specific needs before making a decision.

What should I do if I encounter issues with fulfillment?

If you face challenges with your fulfillment process, consult Shopify’s help center or reach out to your fulfillment provider for support. Regularly review your settings to ensure they align with your business needs.


Participation is optional and ShipAid is not insurance. It does not provide indemnification for loss, damage, or liability. Instead, it allows brands to offer a free replacement if an item is not delivered or arrives in unsatisfactory condition. ShipAid does not sell or ship products, but provides tools for brands to manage replacements. All resolution decisions are made by the brand and may require proof of damage or non-delivery or other information

Similar posts

Read, Protect, & Prosper

Start for free ($0/mo), No strings attached

Protect Your Shipments & Boost Your Profits, It's That Simple.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
White checkmark icon
Free Expert Installation
White checkmark icon
Cancel anytime