Ecommerce

How to Deal with Stolen Packages: A Comprehensive Guide for E-commerce Merchants

May 20, 2025
8 min read

Introduction

Picture this: you’ve been eagerly awaiting the arrival of a package that contains something special—a gift for a loved one, a new gadget, or maybe even an essential supply for your business. You receive the notification that it has been delivered, and with excitement, you rush to your doorstep, only to be met with disappointment—there’s no package in sight.

This scenario is increasingly common, with research indicating that nearly 49 million Americans experienced package theft in the last year alone. As e-commerce continues to thrive, so too does the problem of “porch piracy.” The implications extend beyond mere inconvenience; they can damage customer trust and impact your bottom line.

At ShipAid, we believe that every package matters and that robust shipping protection is key to both customer satisfaction and business revenue. In this post, we will explore how to deal with stolen packages effectively, offering actionable insights that can empower e-commerce merchants to turn a potentially negative experience into a positive outcome.

By the end of this guide, you will understand the steps to take when a package goes missing, how to report theft, and strategies to minimize future risks. We will also discuss how our innovative shipping protection solutions, such as our Delivery Guarantee and intuitive Resolution Portal, can safeguard your shipments and convert lost packages into profits.

Understanding the Problem of Package Theft

In recent years, package theft has surged, especially with the increase in online shopping. The COVID-19 pandemic has further accelerated this trend, leading to more people relying on home deliveries. According to the latest statistics, package theft incidents have increased significantly during the holiday season, with many consumers becoming victims of porch pirates.

Understanding the patterns and motivations behind package theft can help you better prepare and protect your business. Thieves often target deliveries left unattended on doorsteps, porches, or in mailboxes. They may not discriminate based on the value of the items; even small packages can attract unwanted attention.

The Financial Impact on Merchants

When a package is stolen, it doesn’t just affect the customer; it can also have financial repercussions for e-commerce merchants. According to industry reports, the average value of stolen goods can amount to billions of dollars annually. This financial burden can lead to increased shipping costs, loss of sales, and damage to the merchant’s reputation.

Setting Expectations with Customers

A critical aspect of managing shipping and handling for e-commerce is setting clear expectations with customers. Transparency about shipping policies, delivery times, and potential risks can help mitigate disappointment. Customers should feel confident in your ability to handle issues when they arise, and that’s where we come in with our innovative tools designed specifically to protect shipments.

Steps to Take When a Package is Stolen

So, what should you do if you find yourself or your customers in the unfortunate situation of a stolen package? Here are the steps we recommend taking:

1. Confirm Delivery Status

Before jumping to conclusions, it’s essential to confirm that the package was indeed delivered. Sometimes, delivery companies may update tracking information prematurely.

  • Check Tracking Information: Utilize the tracking link provided by the shipping carrier to verify the last known status of the package.
  • Contact the Carrier: If the tracking indicates delivery, but the package is missing, reach out to the shipping carrier. They may have additional insights into the delivery process.

2. Check Surroundings and Neighbors

In some cases, packages may be placed in an unusual location for safety, or they might have been delivered to a neighbor.

  • Look Thoroughly: Check around your porch, back door, or any other places where the delivery driver might have left the package.
  • Ask Neighbors: Sometimes, delivery drivers leave packages with neighbors if they believe it’s safer. A quick chat with your neighbors may yield positive results.

3. Document the Incident

If the package is confirmed stolen, documentation is crucial for reporting the theft and seeking resolution.

  • Take Photos: Document the area where the package was supposed to be delivered, and any relevant surroundings.
  • Keep Tracking Information: Save all tracking details and any notifications received regarding the shipment.

4. Report the Theft

Once you have confirmed that the package is stolen, the next step is to report the incident.

  • File a Claim with the Carrier: Each shipping company has its process for handling stolen packages. For instance:

    • FedEx: You can file a claim online. Make sure to have the tracking number handy.
    • UPS: Contact the sender to initiate a trace process since claims can only be filed 24 hours after delivery.
    • USPS: Fill out a Missing Mail Search Request if your package is not found within a week.
  • Notify the Retailer: If the package was purchased from a retailer, reach out to their customer service. Many retailers have policies in place to handle lost or stolen items, often offering refunds or replacements.

5. File a Police Report

While it might seem unnecessary, filing a police report can be beneficial, especially if the theft is part of a larger trend in your neighborhood.

  • Provide Evidence: Include any documentation you collected, such as photos and tracking information.
  • Follow Up: Keep a record of the report and any correspondence with law enforcement.

6. Explore Insurance Options

If you have homeowners or renters insurance, check if package theft is covered. Many policies include personal property coverage that can help mitigate your losses.

  • Contact Your Insurance Provider: Discuss the details of the incident and ask about the claims process.

7. Utilize Credit Card Protections

Many credit cards offer purchase protection, allowing you to file a claim for stolen items.

  • Check with Your Card Issuer: Understand what protections are available under your card policy and how to initiate a claim.

Preventing Future Package Theft

Dealing with stolen packages can be frustrating, but there are proactive measures we can take to reduce the likelihood of future thefts.

1. Invest in Package Protection

At ShipAid, we understand the importance of protecting your shipments. Our innovative Delivery Guarantee and customizable shipping protection solutions reduce the risk of lost, stolen, or damaged orders. By integrating our service, you can turn potential losses into opportunities for increased revenue.

2. Install Security Measures

  • Cameras: Consider installing a doorbell camera or outdoor security cameras to monitor package deliveries.
  • Lighting: Ensure that your entryways are well-lit to deter potential thieves.

3. Use Secure Delivery Options

  • Package Lockers: Utilize service options like Amazon Hub Locker or local delivery lockers that can securely hold your packages until you can pick them up.
  • Delivery Instructions: Provide specific instructions to your delivery driver, such as leaving packages in a secure location or with a neighbor.

4. Communicate with Customers

As e-commerce merchants, we have a responsibility to inform our customers about potential risks.

  • Set Clear Expectations: Provide information about shipping policies, including the potential for package theft and the steps taken to mitigate risks.
  • Promote Protective Services: Encourage customers to opt for shipping protection solutions like those offered by ShipAid, which can enhance their shopping experience and provide peace of mind.

5. Coordinate with Neighbors

Building a sense of community can help in preventing package theft.

  • Neighborhood Watch: Collaborate with neighbors to keep an eye on each other’s deliveries.
  • Package Sharing: Consider creating a system where neighbors can collect packages for one another when someone is away.

Conclusion

Dealing with stolen packages can be a challenging experience, but it doesn’t have to be the end of the road. By following the steps outlined in this guide, we can empower ourselves and our customers to effectively handle package theft, report incidents, and take preventive measures for the future.

At ShipAid, we believe that every package matters, and we are committed to providing e-commerce merchants with transparent, customizable shipping protection solutions that not only reduce risks but also create a direct revenue stream through our innovative Delivery Guarantee model.

As we navigate the complexities of e-commerce together, let’s turn challenges into opportunities for growth and customer satisfaction. We invite you to explore our interactive demo and experience how our shipping protection works in real-time. Protect your business and build trust with your customers by integrating our free-to-install app today!

FAQ

Are carriers responsible for stolen packages?

Generally, carriers like USPS, UPS, and FedEx have policies regarding stolen packages, but their liability can vary. If you have insurance, you may be able to recover losses through the shipping company.

How do I report a stolen or missing Amazon package?

If your Amazon package tracking shows delivery but you haven’t received it, check with your neighbors first. Then, you can initiate a claim within 36 hours if the package is not found.

Do police investigate missing packages?

The police may investigate if there are leads or if the theft is part of a larger trend in your area. Having evidence such as security camera footage can increase the chances of a successful investigation.

What can I do to protect my packages from being stolen?

Consider using delivery lockers, installing security cameras, or scheduling deliveries for times when you are home. Additionally, using package protection through services like ShipAid can provide extra security.

Is package theft covered by homeowners insurance?

Many homeowners and renters insurance policies cover personal property, including stolen packages. Check your policy for specifics and any limits on coverage for high-value items.

Similar posts

Read, Protect, & Prosper

Start for free ($0/mo), No strings attached

Protect Your Shipments & Boost Your Profits, It's That Simple.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
White checkmark icon
Free Expert Installation
White checkmark icon
Cancel anytime