Ecommerce

What Happens to Stolen Packages? Understanding the Journey from Purchase to Recovery

June 9, 2025
10 min read

Picture this: You’ve eagerly anticipated the arrival of a package—maybe it’s a new gadget you’ve wanted for months, a thoughtful gift for a loved one, or a crucial component for your business. The tracking information indicates it has been delivered, but when you rush to the doorstep, there’s nothing but an empty space where it should have been. What happens now? What are your options when faced with the frustration of a stolen package?

This scenario is increasingly common in the world of ecommerce, as online shopping continues to surge. With the convenience of home delivery comes the risk of package theft, often referred to as “porch piracy.” We know that every package matters and that robust shipping protection is key to customer satisfaction and business revenue. At ShipAid, we’re committed to providing ecommerce merchants with innovative shipping protection solutions that not only reduce the risk of lost, stolen, or damaged orders but also create a direct revenue stream through our Delivery Guarantee model.

In this blog post, we will delve into what happens to stolen packages, the responsibilities of various stakeholders, and how you can protect both your business and your customers. By the end, you’ll have a comprehensive understanding of the steps to take if a package goes missing, how to improve delivery security, and the benefits of utilizing shipping protection services like those we offer at ShipAid.

The Rise of Package Theft: Understanding Porch Piracy

Porch piracy is a term that has emerged in recent years as package deliveries have become a routine part of our lives. According to a study by the insurance company, Shorr Packaging, approximately 36% of Americans reported having a package stolen at least once. This alarming statistic emphasizes the need for protective measures.

Why Does Porch Piracy Happen?

As more consumers shift towards online shopping, the number of packages delivered to homes has skyrocketed. Unfortunately, this has created an opportunity for thieves. Here are a few reasons why package theft is on the rise:

  • Increased Deliveries: With the surge in ecommerce, delivery services are working harder than ever to meet demand, often leaving packages unattended.
  • Lack of Security: Many homes lack adequate security systems, making it easier for thieves to snatch packages without being detected.
  • Opportunistic Behavior: Some individuals may follow delivery trucks around neighborhoods, waiting for the perfect moment to steal unattended packages.

Understanding these factors not only highlights the importance of shipping protection but also showcases how we at ShipAid strive to empower merchants to take proactive steps against theft.

The Emotional Impact of Package Theft

The loss of a package can be more than just a financial setback; it can also lead to feelings of frustration and helplessness. Consumers may feel violated, especially if the item was a gift or something they were looking forward to. As merchants, we recognize that customer trust is a cornerstone of our business. By offering reliable shipping protection, we can help restore that trust and provide peace of mind.

What Happens When a Package is Stolen?

When a package goes missing, the responsibility for resolution typically falls on several parties: the retailer, the shipping carrier, and the customer. Here’s a breakdown of what usually happens:

1. Customer Action

The first step for a customer who suspects their package has been stolen is to check the delivery status. They should ensure that the tracking information confirms delivery and that they’ve checked around their property for the package.

  • Contact the Retailer: Most retailers are the first point of contact for customers. They may have specific policies in place for addressing stolen packages. At ShipAid, we advocate for transparent communication between merchants and their customers to streamline the resolution process.

  • File a Police Report: In many cases, especially if the item is of significant value, customers may consider filing a police report. This can be particularly important for insurance claims or if the item was stolen in a neighborhood with recurring theft issues.

2. Retailer Responsibility

Once the customer has reached out, the retailer’s responsibility comes into play. Depending on their policies, retailers may:

  • Offer Refunds or Replacements: Many retailers have policies that allow them to refund or replace lost items, especially if they are backed by shipping protection. This is where having a service like ShipAid can be invaluable, as our Delivery Guarantee model can help merchants convert a potential loss into a revenue opportunity.

  • Investigate the Claim: Retailers often need to verify the claim, which may involve checking delivery reports or requiring proof of theft. This is a crucial step to ensure that they are not subject to fraudulent claims.

3. Shipping Carrier Involvement

The role of the shipping carrier, such as FedEx or UPS, also plays a significant part in the resolution process:

  • Proof of Delivery: Carriers typically provide proof of delivery, which can include a timestamp and sometimes a photo of where the package was left. This evidence may be necessary for the retailer to process a claim.

  • Claims Process: In some cases, if the package was insured or if the carrier has specific policies for theft, customers can file a claim directly with the shipping company. However, as noted by many industry experts, carriers usually consider their responsibility fulfilled once they deliver the package to the designated address.

Summary of Responsibilities

In summary, when a package is stolen, the responsibility for resolution may shift between the customer, the retailer, and the shipping carrier. This can create confusion and frustration for the customer and underscores the need for clear communication and effective shipping protection solutions.

How to Protect Your Packages from Theft

As ecommerce merchants, we have a responsibility to help our customers protect their packages. Here are several strategies that can reduce the risk of theft:

1. Offer Delivery Options

Customers appreciate flexibility when it comes to delivery. By offering options like:

  • Signature Confirmation: Require a signature upon delivery for high-value items, ensuring they are handed directly to the customer.
  • Delivery to Secure Locations: Encourage customers to choose delivery to secure locations, such as retail pickup points or lockers.

These options can significantly decrease the likelihood of packages being stolen.

2. Enhance Communication

Keeping customers informed can build trust and improve their overall experience. We at ShipAid believe in the power of communication, so consider implementing:

  • Real-Time Notifications: Send updates at each stage of the delivery process, so customers know exactly when to expect their packages.
  • Clear Return Policies: Make sure customers are aware of your return and replacement policies should theft occur.

3. Implement Shipping Protection Solutions

At ShipAid, we empower merchants by offering shipping protection solutions that safeguard shipments and convert lost packages into profits. Here are some of the key features we provide:

  • Delivery Guarantee: Our innovative model ensures that merchants can recover lost revenue from stolen packages, helping to mitigate the financial impact of theft.
  • Resolution Portal: Our intuitive portal simplifies the claim process for both merchants and their customers, providing a seamless experience that builds trust.
  • Advanced Tracking: Real-time tracking allows customers to follow their packages closely, increasing their awareness and reducing anxiety around potential theft.

Summary of Protection Strategies

By implementing these protective measures, merchants can not only reduce the risk of package theft but also enhance customer satisfaction, ultimately leading to increased loyalty and revenue.

What to Do After a Package is Stolen

If you or your customers find themselves in the unfortunate situation of having a package stolen, here’s a step-by-step guide to navigate the aftermath:

1. Confirm Delivery Status

Always start by double-checking the tracking information to ensure that the package was indeed marked as delivered.

2. Search for the Package

Conduct a thorough search around the property. Sometimes packages may be left in unconventional places or with neighbors.

3. Contact the Retailer

Reach out to the retailer as soon as possible. Provide them with the tracking number and any relevant details about the purchase.

4. File a Police Report

If the item is of significant value, consider filing a police report. This can be especially important for insurance claims.

5. File a Claim with the Shipping Carrier

If applicable, file a claim with the shipping carrier. This step may be more straightforward if the item was insured.

6. Review Security Measures

After resolving the immediate issue, consider reviewing and improving security measures at home. This could include installing security cameras or utilizing package delivery services that offer secure drop-off options.

Summary of Post-Theft Actions

These steps help guide customers through the process of recovering from a stolen package, ensuring they feel supported and informed throughout the ordeal.

Conclusion: Building Trust Through Shipping Protection

As ecommerce continues to grow, the risk of package theft remains a significant concern for both merchants and consumers. At ShipAid, we believe that reliable delivery is the foundation of customer trust and business growth. By offering robust shipping protection solutions, we empower merchants to safeguard shipments and convert lost packages into profits.

We understand that every package matters, and that’s why we’re dedicated to providing transparent, customizable shipping protection solutions. Our mission is to reduce the risk of lost, stolen, or damaged orders while creating a direct revenue stream through our innovative Delivery Guarantee model.

As we’ve explored in this post, the journey of a package—from purchase to potential theft—can be complicated. However, with the right strategies, communication, and protective measures in place, we can mitigate these risks and enhance customer satisfaction. Together, let’s work to ensure that every package is protected and every order is a revenue opportunity.

FAQ Section: Common Questions About Stolen Packages

What should I do if my package says it was delivered but I didn’t receive it?

First, confirm the delivery status through tracking information. Check around your property and with neighbors. If you still can’t find it, contact the retailer for assistance.

Am I responsible for a stolen package?

Responsibility can vary depending on the retailer’s policy and whether any shipping protection was purchased. Generally, retailers are often the first point of contact for stolen packages.

Can I file a claim with the shipping carrier?

Yes, if the package was insured or if the carrier has specific policies for theft, you can file a claim with them. Be sure to have all necessary documentation ready.

How can I prevent my packages from being stolen in the future?

Consider using delivery options like signature confirmation, secure drop-off locations, and investing in security measures such as cameras or smart delivery boxes.

Does ShipAid offer solutions for stolen packages?

Absolutely! At ShipAid, we provide shipping protection solutions that help merchants safeguard their shipments and convert lost packages into profits through our Delivery Guarantee model. Explore our interactive demo to see how our solutions can work for your business.

By taking proactive steps and using our innovative shipping protection tools, we can work together to combat the challenges of package theft and enhance the overall ecommerce experience. Explore our interactive demo and discover how our shipping protection works in real time by visiting ShipAid Demo. For more information on our app, check out our listing on the Shopify App Store. Let’s ensure that every package is protected!


Participation is optional and ShipAid is not insurance. It does not provide indemnification for loss, damage, or liability. Instead, it allows brands to offer a free replacement if an item is not delivered or arrives in unsatisfactory condition. ShipAid does not sell or ship products, but provides tools for brands to manage replacements. All resolution decisions are made by the brand and may require proof of damage or non-delivery or other information

Similar posts

Read, Protect, & Prosper

Start for free ($0/mo), No strings attached

Protect Your Shipments & Boost Your Profits, It's That Simple.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
White checkmark icon
Free Expert Installation
White checkmark icon
Cancel anytime