Ecommerce

What to Do If an Expensive Package Is Stolen: A Comprehensive Guide

June 9, 2025
9 min read

When we eagerly anticipate a package filled with something special—perhaps a highly sought-after gadget, a custom piece of jewelry, or even a gift for a loved one—the last thing we expect is to find an empty doorstep upon arrival. Unfortunately, package theft is an increasingly common issue, with millions of Americans experiencing this disheartening scenario each year. According to a report from Security.org, around 49 million Americans had at least one package stolen in the last 12 months alone, highlighting the importance of being prepared for the unexpected.

At ShipAid, we understand that every package matters, and robust shipping protection is key to both customer satisfaction and business revenue. Our mission is to empower e-commerce merchants with innovative tools that safeguard shipments and turn lost packages into profits. In this blog post, we’ll outline practical steps on what to do if an expensive package is stolen, as well as preventative measures to help protect your deliveries in the future.

Introduction

Have you ever experienced the heart-sinking moment when you discover that a package you were eagerly awaiting has vanished? If so, you’re not alone. The rise of e-commerce has brought about a parallel increase in package theft, often referred to as “porch piracy.” This issue is not only frustrating but can also lead to significant financial losses, especially when the item is expensive.

In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the necessary steps to take immediately after discovering your expensive package is stolen. We’ll discuss how to report the theft, seek restitution, and protect yourself against future thefts. By the end of this post, you’ll be equipped with the knowledge to navigate this unfortunate situation and enhance the security of your deliveries.

We’ll cover the following key topics:

  • The initial steps to take when a package is missing
  • How to report the theft
  • Seeking refunds or replacements from sellers and delivery companies
  • Utilizing insurance options
  • Strategies for preventing package theft in the future

Let’s dive in and explore these essential aspects together.

Understanding the Package Theft Landscape

Before we jump into the steps you should take if your package is stolen, it’s crucial to comprehend the broader context of package theft. As online shopping continues to soar, so does the incidence of theft. The convenience of doorstep delivery, while beneficial, has made it easier for thieves to target unsuspecting customers.

The Impact of Package Theft

According to the same Security.org report, the median value of stolen merchandise is around $50, totaling approximately $2.4 billion in stolen goods last year. Such staggering figures indicate that package theft isn’t merely a minor inconvenience; it’s a major concern for consumers and businesses alike.

Moreover, the emotional toll it takes is considerable. The feeling of being violated, coupled with the financial loss, can leave customers feeling vulnerable. This is where reliable shipping protection solutions, like those offered by ShipAid, come into play. Our focus is on creating a seamless post-purchase experience, ensuring that every package is protected and every order is a potential revenue opportunity.

What to Do When Your Expensive Package Is Stolen

If you find yourself in the unfortunate situation of having an expensive package stolen, here’s a step-by-step guide to help you address the issue effectively:

1. Confirm Delivery

Before jumping to conclusions, make sure the package was indeed delivered. Start by checking:

  • Tracking Information: Log into your shipping provider’s website or app to confirm the delivery status. Sometimes, packages are marked as delivered even when they haven’t reached your doorstep.
  • Delivery Time: Note the exact time of delivery and compare it with your schedule. Were you home? Did you see the delivery vehicle?

2. Check Surroundings

Sometimes, delivery drivers leave packages in less visible spots or with neighbors. Take the following steps:

  • Look Around: Check your porch, backyard, or any other areas where the package might have been placed for safety.
  • Ask Household Members: Ensure that no one in your household collected the package without informing you.
  • Speak with Neighbors: Occasionally, delivery drivers leave packages with nearby residents. Ask your neighbors if they received your package by mistake.

3. Document What Happened

If you’ve confirmed that the package is indeed missing, start documenting the situation:

  • Take Photos: Capture images of the delivery notification, the area where it was supposed to be delivered, and any relevant details that could help your case later.
  • Record Details: Note the delivery date, the tracking number, and the item’s value. This information will be crucial when you report the theft.

4. Report the Theft

Once you have confirmed that your package is stolen, it’s time to take action:

  • File a Police Report: Contact your local police department to report the theft. Though the police may not always be able to recover the package, having an official report can aid in claims and provide documentation for your records.
  • Notify the Delivery Company: Depending on the shipping service used, the process for reporting a stolen package varies:
    • FedEx / UPS: You can file a claim online. Generally, this must be done within 60 days of the shipment date for domestic packages.
    • USPS: Start by filling out a Help Request form online to notify your local post office, and if you don’t recover your parcel, proceed with a Missing Mail Search Request.

5. Contact the Retailer

Next, reach out to the seller or retailer from whom you purchased the item:

  • Explain the Situation: Let them know that the package was confirmed as delivered but has not been received.
  • Inquire About Their Policy: Many retailers have policies in place for lost or stolen items. They may offer a replacement or refund, particularly if you can provide proof of delivery.

6. Explore Insurance Options

If you had purchased insurance for your package, you could file a claim for the stolen item:

  • Homeowners or Renters Insurance: Many policies cover theft of personal belongings, including packages. Check your policy limits and coverage details.
  • Credit Card Protections: If you used a credit card for your purchase, check to see if it offers purchase protection. Some cards allow you to file claims for stolen items.

7. Use the Resolution Portal

If you’re a merchant using ShipAid, our intuitive Resolution Portal can streamline the process of handling lost or stolen packages. With our platform, you can efficiently manage claims and resolutions, ensuring a seamless experience for your customers.

Preventing Future Package Theft

While it’s essential to know what to do if an expensive package is stolen, prevention is key. Here are some effective strategies to help protect your packages from theft:

1. Use Delivery Instructions

Many shipping companies allow you to add specific delivery instructions. Consider the following options:

  • Request a Signature: This ensures that packages are only released to you or an authorized person.
  • Specify a Safe Location: Instruct the delivery driver to leave packages in a concealed area, such as behind a planter or in a garage.

2. Install Security Features

Enhancing the security of your delivery area can deter thieves:

  • Outdoor Security Cameras: Install visible cameras to monitor packages and deter potential thieves. Many modern systems allow you to view live feeds from your phone.
  • Doorbell Cameras: A doorbell camera captures footage of anyone approaching your doorstep, providing evidence in case of theft.

3. Utilize Package Lockers

Consider using package lockers or delivery services that offer secure drop-off options:

  • Amazon Lockers: If you frequently order from Amazon, you can have your packages delivered to a nearby locker for secure pickup.
  • Local Delivery Services: Some local businesses offer package receiving services, allowing you to pick up items at their location.

4. Work with Neighbors

Building a sense of community can be beneficial for package security:

  • Neighborly Arrangements: Coordinate with trusted neighbors to receive packages on your behalf when you’re not home.

5. Invest in Package Insurance

For particularly valuable items, consider purchasing additional package insurance for peace of mind. ShipAid offers a customizable Delivery Guarantee that can help reduce the risk of lost, stolen, or damaged orders while also creating a revenue stream through our innovative solutions.

Conclusion

Experiencing package theft, especially for an expensive item, can be a frustrating ordeal. However, by following the steps outlined above, you can navigate the situation effectively and reduce the likelihood of it occurring in the future. Remember, at ShipAid, we’re committed to ensuring that every package matters. With our shipping protection solutions, we empower e-commerce merchants to safeguard their shipments and turn potential losses into revenue opportunities.

If you’re interested in seeing how our solutions work in real-time, we encourage you to explore our interactive demo here and check out our free-to-install app on the Shopify App Store here.

FAQ

What should I do first if my package is stolen?

Start by confirming that the package was indeed delivered and check around your home and with neighbors. If it’s confirmed stolen, document the details and report it to the police and delivery company.

Can I get a refund for a stolen package?

Yes, you can usually receive a refund or replacement by contacting the retailer or seller. If the package was insured, you might also file a claim with your insurance provider.

How can I prevent package theft in the future?

Consider using delivery instructions, installing security cameras, utilizing package lockers, and coordinating with neighbors for package pickups.

Does homeowners insurance cover stolen packages?

Many homeowners and renters insurance policies cover theft, including stolen packages. Check your policy for specific coverage details.

What shipping protection solutions does ShipAid offer?

ShipAid provides a Delivery Guarantee, an intuitive Resolution Portal, real-time Notifications, and advanced Tracking solutions to safeguard shipments and enhance the post-purchase experience for e-commerce merchants.


Participation is optional and ShipAid is not insurance. It does not provide indemnification for loss, damage, or liability. Instead, it allows brands to offer a free replacement if an item is not delivered or arrives in unsatisfactory condition. ShipAid does not sell or ship products, but provides tools for brands to manage replacements. All resolution decisions are made by the brand and may require proof of damage or non-delivery or other information

Similar posts

Read, Protect, & Prosper

Start for free ($0/mo), No strings attached

Protect Your Shipments & Boost Your Profits, It's That Simple.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
White checkmark icon
Free Expert Installation
White checkmark icon
Cancel anytime